Representative image (stock photo); not the exact product.
A Falling Window Box Is Dangerous
A planted window box holding wet compost is heavy, and one falling from an upper floor onto a pavement is capable of causing serious injury.
Brackets fixed into masonry rather than into window frames or render, and a restraint strap or chain as a secondary fixing, is the correct arrangement.
That matters most above a public footpath, where the consequence of a failure involves somebody who had no part in installing it.
Shallow Containers Dry Out Fast
A window box holds a small volume of compost in a shallow layer with a large surface area, which dries out considerably faster than a pot of the same volume.
In summer that means daily watering, and a box in full sun on a south-facing wall can need it twice.
Water-retaining granules and a mulch of gravel on the surface both slow it meaningfully, and a self-watering box with a reservoir is the genuine solution.
Drainage And What Sits Underneath
Water running from a window box stains a wall and drips onto whatever is below, which above a doorway or a seating area becomes a nuisance quickly.
A drip tray or an inner liner that holds a little water addresses it, and a box with no drainage at all waterlogs and kills the plants.
Holes drilled in a solid decorative box are frequently necessary, since many are sold as planters without drainage of any kind.
Plant Choice For A Small Volume
Deep-rooted plants and anything vigorous outgrow a window box within a season, and compact bedding, herbs, succulents and trailing plants suit it.
Mixing upright, filling and trailing plants is the standard approach that makes a box look full rather than sparse.
A box in deep shade needs different planting entirely, and putting sun-loving bedding on a north-facing sill is the commonest reason a box fails.
Railing-mounted boxes hang from a balcony rail rather than fixing to a wall, which suits rented flats where drilling is not permitted and which relies entirely on the hooks holding. Wind is the specific risk there, since a box hanging on the outside of a railing above a street is exactly the arrangement that causes harm when it fails. Mounting on the inside of a railing removes that risk entirely and costs nothing but a little floor space.
Depth affects what can be grown far more than length, since a narrow sill box takes only small bedding where a deeper one supports herbs with real root systems.
Material, Weight And Frost
Terracotta looks best, weighs the most and cracks in frost when wet compost expands inside it.
Plastic and fibreglass are light and frost-proof and look less good, and lining a decorative box with a plastic liner combines the two.
Weight matters for the fixing, and a heavy box on a marginal bracket is a considerably worse combination than a light one.
The Verdict
An effective way to plant where there is no ground, provided the fixing is done properly and watering is realistic.
Shallow compost dries within a day, run-off stains walls, and terracotta cracks in frost.
Fix it into masonry with a secondary restraint. A window box falling on a pavement can seriously injure somebody.
At a glance
Pros
- Planting where there is no ground at all
- Transforms a blank wall or window
- Self-watering versions remove daily watering
- Suits herbs within reach of a kitchen
Cons
- Dries out within a day in summer sun
- Run-off stains walls and drips below
- Terracotta cracks in frost
- Falling boxes are a genuine safety risk
Frequently asked questions
How do I fix it safely?
Brackets into masonry rather than into a window frame or render, plus a restraint strap or chain as a secondary fixing. A planted box full of wet compost falling from an upper floor can seriously injure somebody below.
Why does it dry out so fast?
Small volume, shallow layer, large surface area. In summer that means daily watering and twice daily in full sun on a south wall. Retaining granules and a gravel mulch help; a self-watering reservoir box solves it.
What should I plant in it?
Compact bedding, herbs, succulents and trailing plants. Deep-rooted or vigorous plants outgrow it within a season. Match the planting to the aspect — sun-loving bedding on a north-facing sill is the usual reason a box fails.
Specifications
| Type | Window box or railing planter |
| Critical | Fixing into masonry plus a restraint |
| Watering | Daily, or twice in full sun |
| Mitigation | Retaining granules, gravel mulch |
| Best solution | Self-watering reservoir box |
| Drainage | Required; drill decorative boxes |
| Planting | Compact, trailing, shallow rooted |
| Material | Plastic liner inside terracotta |
The bottom line
Fix it into masonry with a restraint, and expect to water daily. Shallow compost dries within a day.
Check Price on Amazon